Do the Knicks’ Rookies Deserve More of a Shot?

Alex and Gavin discuss the merits and demerits of playing the rookies more

NBA: Washington Wizards at New York Knicks

Nov 18, 2024; New York, New York, USA; New York Knicks guard Pacome Dadiet (4) during the third quarter against the Washington Wizards at Madison Square Garden. Mandatory Credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Brad Penner/Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Gavin: Alex, let’s dive into the Knicks’ rookies. Do you think they deserve more playing time?

Alex: Absolutely, Gavin. Pacome Dadiet is a standout. His defensive skills are exactly what we need, especially with our star wings struggling. Remember his lockdown performance against the Nets?

Gavin: Hold on, Alex. Dadiet’s got potential, but he’s still raw. Sure, he’s got the height and IQ, but can we really trust him in high-pressure situations? Mikal Bridges is logging heavy minutes for a reason.

Alex: I get that, but Dadiet’s shooting from beyond the arc is promising. We need someone to step up and give our key players a breather. He’s shown he can be that guy.

Gavin: But is he ready to handle the NBA’s physicality? We can’t afford to gamble on potential when we’re trying to win games now.

Alex: Fair point, but let’s talk centers. Ariel Hukporti has shown real potential, especially with his shot-blocking. Four blocks in one game is impressive. He could be the spark we need.

Gavin: I disagree. Jericho Sims is our guy. He’s reliable, excels in offensive rebounding, and sets solid screens. Hukporti might have potential, but Sims is the steady presence we need right now.

Alex: Sims is steady, but Hukporti offers a different skill set. We need depth at center, especially while waiting for Precious Achiuwa to return. Hukporti could fill that gap.

Gavin: I see your point, but Sims is like the heart-healthy choice—reliable and steady. We can’t risk experimenting when consistency is key.

Alex: It’s a balancing act, but the depth and potential of these rookies are exciting. As the season progresses, it’ll be interesting to see how they develop and contribute.

Gavin: And what about Tyler Kolek? His shooting is impressive, but his defense is lacking. We can’t sacrifice defense for offense, especially with our current lineup.

Alex: Kolek’s offensive potential is undeniable. He could be a Brunson light, offering dynamic passing and scoring. We should nurture that talent, even if it means taking some risks.

Gavin: Risks are fine, but not at the expense of our current momentum. Cam Payne is playing well, and we can’t disrupt that flow for a rookie still finding his footing.

Alex: I see your point, but rookies need real-time experience to grow. Kolek’s effort and potential make him worth the investment.

Gavin: We’ll see how it plays out, Alex. It’s a balancing act, and as the season progresses, we’ll find out which rookies can truly make their mark.

Alex: Agreed, Gavin. For more insights, listeners should check out the Locked On Knicks podcast. We dive into these debates and more, exploring the future of our team, including a fun game of “Heads or Thibs,” where one of us is forced to play the role of Tom Thibodeau and make our case against these rooks playing.

MORE FROM LOCKED ON NBA
Franz Wagner showcased his progress on a bigger stage and delivered a moment that should cement his status as an All-Star in the league.
They had a chance to win, and didn’t...
Can the San Antonio Spurs’ rookie sensation Stephon Castle rise above the NBA rookie ladder rankings?
Wiggins is third on the team in scoring averaging 16.2 points, but it’s everything else that has been most impressive